Why People Resist Change: Fear

Not long ago I solved a cryptogram which was a quote from a man that I never heard of. It read, “Only fools and dead men don’t change their minds. Fools won’t. Dead men can’t.” My drive to work each day is about thirty minutes, and when not on the phone I take the time to think as deeply as I can about the issues of the day. On my way in this morning, this quote reemerged in my brain as I thought about the resistance to change that we are experiencing as we move closer and closer to the towns voting regionalization up or down.

There are cadres of people who have been against merging our schools for a very long time. The merging of the districts in a Grades 7 – 12 regional school took place 56 years ago and conversations about bringing in the elementary schools have been going on ever since. Unfortunately some people have taken such a stance against our efforts to change that they have refused to listen and refused to think deeply about the possibilities. Still, we have gained momentum and as the times to vote approach and we have been hit with a barrage of questions and concerns that I jokingly refer to as “scuds.”

You might recall in Operation Desert Storm the United States Military was quite successful in shooting down Scud Missiles fired by Iraqi forces via the Patriot Missile System. These missiles were renowned for both their destructive power yet joked about for their lack of precision. United States media outlets led the American public to believe that these missiles were the equivalent of a child trying to hit a piñata. Blindfold on, stick in hand, swing away and hope you make contact.

Since 2009 information has become increasingly available about how much money has been saved in the consolidation of our offices. Then more information was made available about where new funds will become available. I think it is sad and unfortunate that the only thing we talk about is the money because what we are really trying to do this to make the school system better. Fewer people though seem to care about that. There are about two dozen people in our communities who have taken an active stance against merging our districts, and guess what…..they have no children in the schools.

Over the last couple of years I have read a great deal about change in preparation to complete my doctoral degree at UMASS. There is no shortage of quotes about the difficulties associated with change. Famous quotes date back to the 1500’s when Niccolo Machiavelli is stated to have said, "There is nothing more difficult to take in hand, more perilous to conduct, or more uncertain in its success, than to take the lead in the introduction of a new order of things."

As the regional planning committee has continued to hammer away at fact after fact in support of regionalization, opponents to regionalization have become more vocal with their opinions in hopes of slowing and/or putting a stop to the potential change. But facts have a funny way of messing up opinions, so the opposition has had to call upon a new game plan. The new game plan is rooted in asking questions that haven’t been, or cannot be answered. So much of our energy and time lately has been spent answering questions. In many cases though, those who are asking the questions really don’t care what the answer is. They just hope to find something that is not answered to use as a reason not to regionalize.

The Regional Planning committee has welcomed the questions however. Each and every one has provided an opportunity to provide clarity and deeper understanding of the issue. If you are a regular reader of this blog, you know what I mean when I write about Ground Truth. In preparation for the votes to regionalize I will be posting reasons that certain groups of people will stand against regionalization. In general there are five reasons why people resist change:

1. People in general reject new and different things
2. People are not interested in change because it interferes with goals that they want to pursue
3. People do not understand the messages and consequences that will change their individual situations
4. People do not trust the person or people who are communicating the change
5. The most important reason: Fear

Readers will find that the biggest fear among those who oppose regionalization is rooted in their individual losses of power and control. The next series of blog posts will highlight shifts in power and control that will result from regionalization. Those who read the blog will then have a deeper understanding of why certain groups of people will stand in opposition to this change. This will also provide clarity for voters so that when the time comes they can make the most informed vote as possible.